Caseworkers Allege Unnecessary Trauma and Harsh Treatment of FLDS Women and Children by State

The Salt Lake Tribune reports on some disturbing allegations about the Texas Child Protective Services' treatment of Fundamentalist Latter-day Saints (FLDS) mothers and children in the weeks immediately following the April raid of the FLDS compound.

    Mental health professionals who helped care for FLDS women and children in the weeks after an April raid on the YFZ Ranch describe conditions and treatment they perceived as harsh and unnecessary.
    "Never in all my life, and I am one of the older ladies, have I been so ashamed of being a Texan and seeing what and how our government agencies treat people," wrote one employee of Hill Country Community Mental Health and Mental Retardation Center in an unsigned statement.
    Texas contracts with Hill Country to provide mental health services during disasters. Staff members met with the center's board of trustees last week, leaving them "spellbound." The board has gathered nine written statements critical of Child Protective Services.
    Chairman John Kight said he wants state legislators and the governor to hear the employees' stories. "You have damaged these children for their lives," he said. "This is an agency that looks like it's gone out of control." A Texas CPS spokesman acknowledged the allegations were "very serious" and said they are being investigated. But he noted the women and children were held at a historic fort and a convention center in San Angelo in an unusual emergency situation.

The Salt Lake Tribune provides links to the statements made by the caseworkers.  The San Antonio Express-News also has a story on the allegations that includes the reflections of Kevin Dinnin, the president of Baptist Children and Family Services (BCFS)  "who served as incident commander at the shelter under a contract between his agency and the state."  Dinnin "said he couldn't confirm many of the allegations made by the MHMR workers."  The work of BCFS is discussed in more detail here.

Look below the fold for some of the details from the caseworkers' statements and the responses the state has offered thus far to those allegations.  These details appeared in the Salt Lake Tribune story. 

    Not all Texas CPS employees were criticized by the Hill Country employees. One young man was described as sitting for two hours comforting a toddler separated from his mother. The Texas Rangers were "respectful and polite," according to another statement.
    But the statements focus on the Hill Country staffers' dismay at uncaring behavior they say they witnessed by CPS employees.
    A boy estimated at age 3 walked along a row of cots asking for someone to rock him after he was separated from his mother, one employee wrote. Two CPS worker trailed the youngster taking notes but not helping him. His brother, age 8, eventually took the child into his arms and sat with him in a rocking chair.
    "That little boy will always be in my mind," the employee wrote. "How can a beautiful, healthy child be taken from a healthy, loving home and forced into a situation like that, right here in America, right here in Texas?"
    Mothers who initially were allowed to stay with their children were later required to leave if their child was older than 12 months. Describing that day, one employee wrote, "the floor was literally slick with tears in places."
    After the separation, a baby was allegedly left in a stroller with no food and water for 24 hours and ended up in a hospital, according to another statement.
    "We don't believe that's the case, but we're checking into that," [a state spokesman] said.
    Several of the employees stated they do not condone polygamy or the alleged abusive treatment of children. But, they added, the FLDS mothers were not silent or hostile, as CPS had warned they would be. Instead, they were polite, focused on caring for the children, and willing to establish relationships, the mental health workers said.
    Several writers claimed CPS workers repeatedly lied to the mothers regarding where they were going to be moved to and other issues.
    [A state spokesman] said he disputed that. The state has asserted the FLDS mothers were uncooperative with authorities, such as providing inaccurate or changing information about names and ages.